Is the Business Viable, or Is the Investment Worthwhile? A Two-Level Appraisal of Capacity Investment in an Indonesian Micro-Bakery

Authors

  • Hamdani Hamdani Politeknik Negeri Samarinda, Indonesia
  • Ana Durratunnashiha Politeknik Negeri Samarinda, Indonesia
  • Johan Lucas Away Politeknik Negeri Samarinda, Indonesia
  • Dyah Kusrihandayani Politeknik Negeri Samarinda, Indonesia

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.24256/dinamis.v9i2.13141

Abstract

Micro-enterprises often assess equipment
purchases through owner judgement, while
conventional feasibility studies tend to evaluate the
business as a whole rather than the incremental
investment. This study develops and applies a twolevel appraisal to a planned IDR 4.43 million capacity
investment at Aura Bakery, a micro-producer of roti
gembong in Samarinda, Indonesia. Using a
qualitative single-case design, interviews with the
owner, one employee and two regular customers,
non-participant observation, business records and
capital-budgeting analysis, the study evaluates five
non-financial dimensions and the financial position of
the enlarged business. Whole-business analysis
indicates viability, with an NPV of IDR 67.51 million
at a 12% discount rate and a profitability index of 5.66.
However, these figures do not establish that the new
equipment itself creates value. Incremental analysis
shows that the investment requires 11–16 additional
units sold per month when existing staff absorb
delivery, increasing to 57–85 units when a paid
courier is required. The findings demonstrate that
investment feasibility depends not only on
production capacity but also on demand realisation,
delivery arrangements and regulatory readiness. The
proposed procedure translates the incremental NPV
criterion into a practical demand threshold that
micro-enterprise owners can monitor.

Downloads

Published

2026-11-19

Citation Check